No, the fact it’s so complex is part of the problem. It’s an interesting discussion to be had but it’s not a Shower Thought.
A Shower Thought is something like “If Eminem’s Mom wanted to she could probably make a good amount of money selling her own spaghetti sauce” (stole this from Reddit). It’s a random thought that comes to you, serves no real purpose but still just kind of lingers in your mind.
You definitely could, but it’s not really sustainable.
Worst case scenario: if everybody does this, and there’s 50.000 subscribers on a certain community, then that community will have to update 50.000 other servers whenever one user leaves a single message or vote.
Sure, your own server wouldn’t have a hard time, but it every popular server (with lots of subscribers) would. It would either take a long time for you to receive their updates, or you wouldn’t get them at all.
The best thing you can do, is join a medium size server: it won’t be as overloaded as a big server, and wouldn’t cause as much strain on the fediverse as a personal server.
I can say with full confidence that I have absolutely no idea.
I’ve heard this idea thrown around before, so I take no credit for it: One way to circumvent the issue would be to have actual relay nodes. As in: nodes that don’t hold contents or users themselves, but just “broadcast” incoming messages to several instances, so that the source instances don’t have to. This would of course have its own drawbacks and limitations, but it would alleviate the bottleneck.
I’m sure some kind of solution will be found though. Call me optimistic, but I think the lemmi/binniverse has a bright future ahead of it. I, for one, have burned my reddit bridges.
Or use crypto. Generate keypairs, sign updates. Add support for delegating updates to other instances.
Maybe add support for having instances getting data to indicate if they’re willing to relay update data to others, and have main instance refer to them for a certain time period, say… 6 hours maybe?
Relay willingness would depend on instance config and load, ideally.
Edit: any reason I’m getting down votes? If there is a problem with the approach, at least leave a comment.
Edit2: Crypto as in CRYPTOGRAPHY! Which has been shortened to crypto since long before bitcoin was invented. If this was some non-tech forum I could understand, but a community about self hosting and no one seems to be making the obvious connection? Wow. And you guys host stuff, that’s just scary.
No down vote from me, but surely by now you know how people feel about crypto.
At any rate, I don’t think an immutable ledger is desirable for speech (what’s the point of moderation), perhaps more something like torrent would be preferable. And, as someone else mentioned, relay software already exists.
Who said anything about immutable ledger? I was talking about signing updates so it can be verified when relayed through untrusted third parties.
So if lemmy.world sends an update to lemmy.selfhosted.guy and then lemmy.anotherselfhosted.guy federates with lemmy.world, lemmy.world can then say “Hey, here’s my public key, lemmy.selfhosted.guy have a copy of my data and is willing to be delegated to, you can get the data from him” and then lemmy.world doesn’t have to distribute it’s changes to everyone itself, but maybe just update 5-10 hosts. And the number of relays will scale with the network.
And thanks to the data being signed, you can trust the updates from lemmy.selfhosted.guy being from lemmy.world and not been tampered with, keeping lemmy.world as the authority of the data, even if you don’t trust lemmy.selfhosted.guy.
Edit: This would also mean all the small self hosted instances will boost the network instead of threatening to overload it.
My bad, I thought you meant the other crypto (as did everyone else, presumably). I know cryptography was first, but I think it’s safe to say that that abbreviation has been irrevocably tainted.
yeah, I’m slowly starting to realize that. That a few misunderstood, I could see that. If you’re new to things you’ve probably only heard in connection to cryptocurrencies. But everyone misunderstanding? It’s really shocking. Especially since the context should have made it obvious.
As developer we have crypto libraries. Crypto systems. Crypto layers. Crypto functions… And so on.
Crypto is cryptography. Cryptocurrencies are just a small thing, using cryptography. To have that “take over” the crypto word completely is as unnerving as waking up one day and mentioning to someone you washed your face this morning and they respond “What, like, the screen?” and then discover everyone only thinking of facebook, even with the context.
I’m sorry, I’m rambling. It’s just so unbelievable to me to have this happen in a forum focusing on self hosting services. Where crypto should (hopefully) be daily bread and butter.
We had great success just putting up a little sign on the door that said “no unaddressed mail”.
Of course since we were buying a custom sign for it we also added “…or else”, and one time I just happened to open the door after a young lad had pushed a leaflet through. He sort of stepped backwards a bit and his eyes went down to the sign and he stuttered “I’m so sorry I didn’t see the sign” as if he thought I was about to wallop him.
I opted out multiple times and still get the junk mail. Feel sorry for the posties having to lug all that pointless weight around that just goes straight into the recycling!
I use Bookmark Folder. It works really great.
As default browser (in android settings and bookmark folder settings too) i use URLCheck, from Fdroid. Bookmark Folder URLCheck
I wanted to look at the dev’s privacy policy that’s linked on GPlay coconuts.boy.jp/en/policy/privacy_policy.html and it got blocked by five privacy and ads blocklists. I don’t know if I’d give them my bookmarks.
I think it is quite unfair towards someone to be with them only because otherwise you wouldn’t have any friends. Unless of course you both know about that.
Many people do not invest in relationships and that is the main reason they end up alone. I have seen this in other couples a lot.
For example, my father always tagged along but never had any respect for the work my mother put into relationships with friends and families. When they divorced my father became a grumpy and lonely old man who gets increasingly awkward the longer he spends cooped up alone.
He believes his way out is finding another woman. He seems to be unable to understand that it shouldn’t be another person’s job to “make” his social life…
A partner is no replacement for friends and they can’t be the stand in for all other relationships.
Surely we recall typing code into basic from the back of a magazine. Later we were blown away from having a EGA card that didn’t make text look like crap? Right guys?
Surely we recall typing code into basic from the back of a magazine. Later we were blown away from having a EGA card that didn’t make text look like crap? Right guys?
It’s the same thing that makes any social media attractive: everybody else is there and it’s where things are happening. This critical mass of users is the hardest thing for a website to gain and the hardest to lose.
I feel like part of what caused it to explode is that some celebrities joined up early and it provided a tangible way for fans to interact directly with them. This was totally novel and completely unprecedented. Prior to Twitter you could watch Entertainment Tonight and read People magazine. Twitter let you directly contact celebrities.
I really couldn’t care less about celebrities, which I have always thought is part of why Twitter has always felt kind of pointless to me.
But I fully recognize that for some people that’s a huge draw and I do think it’s a big part of what makes Twitter popular.
Each time a platform reaches enough popularity to attract an average voter, people starts to blame the platform for being stupid. I’m waiting for the day we collectively realize it’s not the platform we hate, it’s the average person.
When you have one guy in town that’s an idiot, that guy is the village idiot. The village idiot know he’s the dumbest guy in town and so will tend to listen to the people smarter than him.
But with the internet you’re getting a lot of people together and letting them find groups they fit into. That’s mostly a good thing.
But all the village idiots get into a group together where they only people they’re talking to are other village idiots. Then they start thinking their idiocy is right. And they stop listening to the people smarter than them.
Then you have a lot of confident idiots who bring everyone down to their level.
kbin.life
Oldest