Karma sucked ass on Reddit. Essentially people could ban you from participating because you pissed too many people off even though you didn’t break any rules.
Karma count is an ass kissing metric, high karma shows that you kiss people’s asses for upvotes, low or negative karma shows that people dislike what you say which is absolutely ok. People having different opinions vs going with the group is the difference between a healthy platform and an echo chamber.
By the way Trolls and malicious actors who that system is targeting should be dealt with directly. If someone’s posting hateful transphobia instead of downvoting their acount they should just be BANNED from the community or the platform as a whole, keep bad people out of the community.
Kicking people because they have different opinions is exactly what we should avoid. We should only ban people if they are not cooperating in making lemmy a better place but labeling certain groups of people as “bad” and banning them while they were only expressing their dissent is not ok.
So you don’t think people who post hateful stuff about trans people or deliberately spread dangerous or hateful misinformation, or people who spam multiple comments at once should be banned from the platform (or at the very least have their comments actioned by mods)? I’m saying that because Reddit originally intended the Downvotes system to be used to combat those specific types of scenarios, they said it was to control spam and malicious actors. These are things that should be dealt with using disciplinary action i.e. being booted.
If it was an agree/disagree system like many people think it is they wouldn’t have added rate limiting to people with low or negative Karma or made it so communities can set karma restrictions. Even so I don’t really think it’s a good method either, it’s almost just a softer less obvious form of shadowban.
I like being able to say what I want without being banned by a power-tripping mod, or downvoted into irrelevance by a circle jerk. We need to be able to point out that the Emperor isn’t wearing clothes.
Well except for those who are here because of a bullshit Reddit ban, but my attitude towards that is “You can’t fire me I quit”
We’re free of the mundanes, I can say what I want as long as I’m not being toxic af! No auto-moderator is going to flag me for using “Ableist Langauge” because I can’t keep with what terms have and haven’t been considered “problematic”
I mean, the word “retard”, obviously (God what places on the Corpo Net can you say THAT word nowadays?), that’s not cool to say. But seriously I had one auto-mod flag me for saying “crazy” because it was “offensive to the mentally unwell”
Bitch I’m bi-polar and literally autistic, I AM mentally unwell, I think I have an n-word pass in this instance… Not that I should need one to say “crazy”
Does karma change that? We still have upvotes and downvotes, and you can sort comments by how well they do, and mods can still ban people not only from a community, but from a whole instance.
I like being able to say what I want without being banned by a power-tripping mod
There’s currently nothing stopping a mod from creating a bot that deletes comments below certain threshold or that bans users for commenting on communities they don’t approve like they did on Reddit. Only site policies can prevent that.
Can site policies even affect that? From my understanding Lemmy/kbin is all decentralized unlike subreddits, so anyone can make and host their page for anyone and the only limit is legality and if they’re not black listed by other instances
Ugh… I remember the “Sorry you have been banned from…” messages, it was amusing when I was banned from subreddits I hadn’t heard of.
Thing is Reddit policies are supposed to make it so you can’t be banned from one subreddit for your reputation or behavior in another, I actually told a mod this and he just laughed at me.
Traveling right now and have a travel bidet. It’s a little bottle with a bidet sprayer nozzle attched. Obviously not as good as the real thing but I can’t go anywhere without it. Lives in my laptop bag permanently.
lemmyshitpost
Active
This magazine is from a federated server and may be incomplete. Browse more on the original instance.