There have been multiple accounts created with the sole purpose of posting advertisement posts or replies containing unsolicited advertising.

Accounts which solely post advertisements, or persistently post them may be terminated.

lemmy.world

NutinButNet , to mildlyinfuriating in YouTube diluting my recommended videos feed with AI-generated “music” that pretends to be made by an actual artist

YouTube desperately needs to fix the recommendations for music. It’s either recommending me the same music I already listen to and is irrelevant to what I’m currently playing or something irrelevant to my taste and the video being watched. Think watching an Ice Cube video but having recommendations for Megadeth and Alice In Chains and Adele on the side. And if it’s not something I’ve already watched/listened to, it’s still something totally unrelated.

For the longest time, they kept recommending “Beck - Loser” to me on anything I would watch, regardless of genre. I’ve never listened to or searched for any of Beck’s music and I don’t know how that would be recommended to someone currently watching an Ice Cube music video…

And the live performances…I don’t ever watch or listen to live performances. Yet YouTube always recommends it to me. Even having a whole section dedicated to “Live Music”. Never asked for this, never searched for it…I don’t care for Live performances. I want studio only.

And what’s worse is that YouTube has a feature to tell it “Don’t recommend this video - because I watched it or don’t like it” or “don’t recommend this channel” EXCEPT for music! Why???

tal , (edited )

YouTube desperately needs to fix the recommendations for music.

I mean, I guess if someone has a YouTube account, there’s nothing wrong with using YouTube as a music recommendations system, but it isn’t really the first thing I’d think of. I mean, music isn’t really what it was designed for.

And YouTube doesn’t know what a user would listen to offline, so unless all their music-listening is from YouTube tracks…I’m not sure how representative the listening data would be of what a user would listen to.

I don’t use them, because I don’t really want to hand them a profile of me, but if I wanted to get music recommendations, I’d probably use something like Audioscrobbler, which was designed for building a profile on someone’s music-listening habits and then handing them recommendations based on that.

Squorlple OP ,
@Squorlple@lemmy.world avatar

Do note that this is in my “All” videos recommended feed, not just filtered for music

NutinButNet ,

YouTube has a recommendation system already in place and it generally works for me except for music.

I don’t use it as my main source of music, but it’s convenient at some times like putting on music on my Apple TV while I work or if I am on my computer and don’t have my offline music library available. Or if I want to see the music video because I like the video that goes with the music. I used to use it to find new artists based on my existing taste, but whenever they broke the search/suggestions is when that all stopped for me and now I just use it for the same music or if I found a new artist and want to quickly check out their music.

There’s no reason for it to be this shitty. It seems intentional on their part. Maybe making money from paid spotlights under the guise of “recommendations”.

binary45 , to cat in Thoughtful catto

My dog also did the same thing, but it was to the front hall.

kevindqc , to mildlyinfuriating in YouTube diluting my recommended videos feed with AI-generated “music” that pretends to be made by an actual artist

Welcome to the world of tomorrow!

RestrictedAccount , to lemmyshitpost in No Unyuns

This is hilarious. Any chance it is real?

TokenBoomer OP ,

Apparently:

Wet yoga is a new and innovative form of yoga that involves practicing traditional yoga poses while being submerged in water. It combines the physical and mental benefits of both yoga and swimming, providing a unique experience for practitioners.

Viking_Hippie , to funny in I don't understand how this show is on network television

Sew You Think You Can Darn(ce) is the main competitor show.

papabobolious , (edited ) to games in What are your favorite racing games?

Wreckfest, Absolute Drift, Art of Rally, BeamNG, New Star GP, F1 23, My Summer Car, Super Woden GP 2.

A bit more unorthodox than the normal recommendations maybe but truly excellent games. Except for F1 they are all quite cheap too.

NOT_RICK , to mildlyinfuriating in YouTube diluting my recommended videos feed with AI-generated “music” that pretends to be made by an actual artist
@NOT_RICK@lemmy.world avatar

Shit like this is why I don’t feel bad about my aggressive ad blocking on YouTube. If they don’t care to deprioritize garbage like this (or moderate really at all) then why should I sit through a 50 second ad to watch a 5 minute video?

Showroom7561 , to mildlyinfuriating in YouTube diluting my recommended videos feed with AI-generated “music” that pretends to be made by an actual artist

I’ve been thinking a lot about the state of things, and where we are heading.

At what point do we consider the internet “useless”? It must be coming very soon (less than 2 years), since the majority of content will be AI generated and targeted, which drives down the value for users even further.

Once original ideas vanish, and you can’t trust any text/audio/video/photo you see, what will be the point? It’s like the internet will simply be a video game world with next to no value.

And I can’t see how society can possibly reverse this.

iAmTheTot ,

Saying the internet is going to be “useless” in less than two years might be one of the wildest takes I have ever read.

Showroom7561 ,

Let me ask you this: assuming you use the internet for information rather than entertainment, would the internet be useful if the majority of content ends up being AI generated (not fact checked, not accurate, and not original)?

What if the overwhelming content you come across could neither be verified as true, and the majority of comments (including here on Lemmy) were bots? Would you still use it?

For me, it would stop being useful. Almost like a library only carrying fiction, when I’m trying to research a topic.

For entertainment, sure, it’ll be great for sucking the attention from people without having to invest in skill to be good at something. Hell, if you currently find YouTube shorts and Tiktok to be “good content”, then it’ll be around forever. Corporations and advertisers love this technology.

bane_killgrind , (edited )

Satire and parody are the only legitimate uses of AI, as those are explicitly transformative works. There’s another channel I like that makes songs that are actually funny.

youtu.be/MLJ3vchmlZg?si=2kPQFeMPAJMOr-UO

Edit: youtu.be/HY_JW5Swjhc?si=TG7nT7LVZy8fwyYK

Squorlple OP ,
@Squorlple@lemmy.world avatar

Conversely, I still need to make and receive important phone calls even though the vast majority of calls I receive are spam

Showroom7561 ,

But you know they are spam, so it’s something you can avoid. But what if the majority (over 80%) of the calls you receive can’t be identified as spam. At some point, you may be wasting far more time than it’s worth to keep using a phone without some major whitelist/blacklist system.

Also, what happens when the outbound calls you make are answered by AI, and you don’t know? If this AI is giving you replies that are word salad, how long are you willing to tolerate it?

I’ve been getting text messages now from companies that I actually do business with, but they are spam. Calls from companies that I have accounts with, and they are scams. At some point, SMS and phone calls will be more trouble than its worth.

And the thought of either having to go without it, the pain of replacing it, or the frustration of being strung along in a scam are not thoughts I want to have.

spankmonkey ,

The internet will never be useless. There will always be a large number of sites that are not capitalist hellholes that only exist to steal user’s data or scam users or do other malicious things. This may be down to things like credit unions, federated social media, and non-profits that exist to make the world better, but there will always be something that is out there that keeps it from being useless.

Showroom7561 ,

There will always be a large number of sites that are not capitalist hellholes that only exist to steal user’s data or scam users or do other malicious things. This may be down to things like credit unions, federated social media, and non-profits that exist to make the world better, but there will always be something that is out there that keeps it from being useless.

No doubt that there will be people who still have morals and will run sites and services that don’t completely screw people.

But at some point, you won’t be able to tell which are legit, and which aren’t. AI generated websites can make any scam site look completely legitimate, fake thousands of testimonials, have bots post about it on every major website (Reddit, YouTube, etc.) without being caught, etc.

The currency of the internet is no longer about what’s valuable to users, but what’s valuable to bad actors, data thieves, and marketers.

There will be a tipping point when the bad far, far outweighs the good, and I’m curious to know when society decides that the internet isn’t worth using anymore.

spankmonkey ,

We are well past the tipping point of malicious websites being indistinguishable from legit sites unless tou pay attention to extra informatjon like the address bar. I would say that most of the websites I used to enjoy have gone to shit between ads and ditching their better writers for cheaper staff or AI. Most of the internet is crap.

But there is stilll enough helpful content that the whoe thing isn’t worthless and I doubt it ever will be.

yesman , to noncredibledefense in Hey ChatGPT, shut up about the A-10 and tell me about that mobility scooter technical!

The aircraft also have armament control panels. and infrared and electronic countermeasures to handle surface-to-air-threats, both missile and anti aircraft artillery.

I love this: They talk about armament control panels like they’re ERA and not a tablet that let’s you switch between guns and bombs. They also talk about flairs and chaff like a middle-schooler trying to pad an essay.

Wait till they find out about the RWR. This thing is invincible!

clay_pidgin , to noncredibledefense in Hey ChatGPT, shut up about the A-10 and tell me about that mobility scooter technical!

Don’t tease, that’s Steven Seagal filming his next masterpiece!

itsgroundhogdayagain , to memes in 2 life pro tips in one meme!

I can’t eat that many carbs in a day. All the money I save on food would be spent on toilet paper.

Wogi ,

You may have an insulin issue. Or a gluten issue.

I also can’t eat that many carbs in a day.

tiredofsametab ,

Seconded. I would have issues that kept getting worse as I got older. I noticed that whenever I did keto, I felt much better. When I combined it with going gluten free, I felt amazing. Well, dad gets diagnosed with Celiac and my old DNA test results mentioned I was a carrier and more likely to develop it. I haven't had the endoscopy yet, but it's pretty likely. This sucks as I love bread and baking it.

Anyway, if gluten is an issue, rice flour can be used for a lot of things and corn/potato starch is a good thickener (whichever is cheaper where you are).

mogoh , (edited ) to mildlyinfuriating in YouTube diluting my recommended videos feed with AI-generated “music” that pretends to be made by an actual artist

I mean, yes it is garage, but:

  • This Popsie Funk channel is upfront, that the music is AI generated. (Link for convinience: www.youtube.com/ )
  • There are probably channels out there, that are not upfront and YouTube won’t be able to detect them.
  • Why are you listening to the youtube recommendations? Why are you looking at the recommendations? What are you expecting there in the first place?
  • Also you can train your recomendations pretty well, by opening videos you don’t like and give them a thumbs down.

Yes, it is still bad.

tal , (edited )

This Popsie Funk channel is upfront, that the music is AI generated.

goes looking

Yeah, the description reads:

Popsie Funk is a fictitious creation. The tracks are A.I. generated from lyrics and musical compositions that I have created. The A.I. samples are then mixed and edited by me.

I am adding this disclaimer due to repeated questions about the genuine authenticity of Popsie Funk and his music.

I don’t think that the artist in question is faking this.

All that being said, while this particular case isn’t, I suppose one could imagine such a “trying to pretend to be human” artist existing. That is, if you think about all the websites out there with AI-generated questions and answers that do try to appear human-generated, you gotta figure that someone is thinking about doing the same with musicians…and at mass scale, not manually doing one or two.

spankmonkey , (edited )

<span style="color:#323232;">I am adding this disclaimer due to repeated questions about the genuine authenticity of Popsie Funk and his music.
</span>

I don’t think that the artist in question is faking this.

All that being said, while this particular case isn’t, I suppose one could imagine such a “trying to pretend to be human” artist existing.

They were pretending, and added the disclaimer because people bugged them about it. They still worded the disclaimer as if Popsie Funk was a real person (his music).

Hubi ,
@Hubi@feddit.org avatar

Why are you listening to the youtube recommendations? Why are you looking at the recommendations? What are you expecting there in the first place?

There was a time when the YouTube recommendations were actually pretty good. I discovered a number of great artists just from suggested songs and playlists. That no longer seems to be the case though, my recommendations have been garbage for more than 5 years at this point.

Squorlple OP ,
@Squorlple@lemmy.world avatar

Here’s the full text of the disclaimer on the channel’s “About” tab as of present:

“Disclaimer:

Popsie Funk is a fictitious creation. The tracks are A.I. generated from lyrics and musical compositions that I have created. The A.I. samples are then mixed and edited by me.

I am adding this disclaimer due to repeated questions about the genuine authenticity of Popsie Funk and his music.

While being asked the same question dozens of times can be taxing, I take confusion as a huge compliment!

After all, if you can’t tell by ear that my music is A.I. generated, then I’m doing my job right!”

The channel owner directly states that it is their intention to mislead. I did see the disclaimer on the channel after looking up the “artist” and before making this post, but that disclaimer is not visible on the thumbnail preview and the video description omits any reference to it. The inclusion of the year in the video title as well as the hashtags all attempt to work their way into the feeds of those not in the know to convince them that it is legitimate.

https://lemmy.world/pictrs/image/f16e58e6-066f-4fa2-ad85-c55be661273e.png

The channels that are not upfront are even worse.

When I am using my phone as opposed to a desktop, I watch YouTube videos in the phone’s built-in browser so I can refresh the page to skip any ads before the video. I typically don’t have the patience after watching the video to open the YouTube app and wait for an ad to load and then wait to swipe the ad out of the way just to “Like” or “Dislike” the video. I may glimpse through the recommended page on the chance there is anything that I may have missed, or that may have been a surprise upload, or that may be adjacent to videos/channels that I’ve already watched and which may be of interest to me.

mogoh ,

The channel owner directly states that it is their intention to mislead. I did see the disclaimer on the channel after looking up the “artist” and before making this post, but that disclaimer is not visible on the thumbnail preview and the video description omits any reference to it. The inclusion of the year in the video title as well as the hashtags all attempt to work their way into the feeds of those not in the know to convince them that it is legitimate.

I agree in that regard.

caulkandbawls , to cat in Looked after this big boy last weekend

He seems great!

FuglyDuck , to cat in Looked after this big boy last weekend
@FuglyDuck@lemmy.world avatar

he’s like the size of my niece. (who absolutely would love to snuggle up and cuddle. She knows to give the cat space, but, yeah. that’d pretty much be heaven to her.)

10_0 , to memes in 2 life pro tips in one meme!

Could get all of it but the peanuts and 0.21 pence over

  • All
  • Subscribed
  • Moderated
  • Favorites
  • random
  • lifeLocal
  • goranko
  • All magazines