There have been multiple accounts created with the sole purpose of posting advertisement posts or replies containing unsolicited advertising.

Accounts which solely post advertisements, or persistently post them may be terminated.

NaNoWriMo is in disarray after organizers defend AI writing tools

The organization behind National Novel Writing Month (NaNoWriMo) is being slammed online after it claimed that opposing the use of AI writing tools is “classist and ableist.” On Saturday, NaNoWriMo published its stance on the technology, announcing that it doesn’t explicitly support or condemn any approach to writing.

“We believe that to categorically condemn AI would be to ignore classist and ableist issues surrounding the use of the technology, and that questions around the use of AI tie to questions around privilege,” NaNoWriMo said, arguing that “not all brains” have the “same abilities” and that AI tools can reduce the financial burden of hiring human writing assistants.

NaNoWriMo’s annual creative writing event is the organization’s flagship program that challenges participants to create a 50,000-word manuscript every November. Last year, the organization said that it accepts novels written with the help of AI apps like ChatGPT but noted that doing so for the entire submission “would defeat the purpose of the challenge.”

PugJesus ,

Fucking horrid.

Samvega ,

not all brains” have the “same abilities” and that AI tools can reduce the financial burden of hiring human writing assistants

The path to equality does not necessarily lie in degrading the value of human creativity.

NaNoWriMo’s annual creative writing event is the organization’s flagship program that challenges participants to create a 50,000-word manuscript every November.

I would prefer to write 1,000 good words slowly than right 50,000 ungood word fastlier.

PugJesus ,

Worst part is, NaNoWriMo is a good practice tool to help people get past the initial apprehension about writing a novel, because a novel-sized work is a big undertaking. Throwing AI in there defeats that purpose.

evidences ,

I used to have a friend that NaNoWriMo every year and would update her progress on live journal. I always took the exercise to be what you’re describe, just an event to get people to write not even particularly well. Having your foundation saying that people not writing in your writing event is wild.

FlyingSquid ,
@FlyingSquid@lemmy.world avatar

I would say that it is a good practice tool in a legitimate way. The same way exercising every day in a low-impact way for a few weeks before moving on to a higher impact workout. The original might not help much building muscles, but they get those muscles prepared for the harder work.

I’m not a writer, but my dad wrote a ton of academic books and my mom writes novels. Both say you have to write every day to keep in practice.

coyootje ,

I can see the benefits of AI in certain fields of work but why would you want it to take over in the creative industry? Isn’t tapping into your own creativity the fun part?

Rosoe ,
@Rosoe@fedia.io avatar

If you have Dyslexia then ChatGPT is a better spellcheck than whatever's in your writing software. I won't pretend to know all the applications of AI to help neurodiverse people to write but there are ways to use AI in writing that is very helpful to them. I wouldn't say having AI blurt out 50,000 words of nothing is particularly helpful to any writer though.

AlexanderESmith ,

If I had any disorder that kept me from interacting with written words effectively, but I had a burning need to tell a particular story, I would either record an audio book, or ask a friend to help me write it down. I sure as hell wouldn't trust an LLM with my work.

AbouBenAdhem ,

Their announcement reads like an update of the classic “If by Whisky” speech.

FlyingSquid ,
@FlyingSquid@lemmy.world avatar

Isn’t the whole point to challenge yourself by writing a novel? I wouldn’t submit whatever I wrote because writing a novel in a month means it’s probably not going to be very good.

I mean I don’t care one way or the other if people use ChatGPT to do this, but it seems like they’re not really challenging themselves.

BottleOfAlkahest ,

Nanowrimo is already in flames because of last years ‘groomer mod’ scandal. Why would they choose now to weigh in on such a controversial topic rather than working on filling all the staff vacancies, rebuilding trust in their community, and developing new volunteers to replace all the ones they fired and ghosted? All they’ve got to do here is keep their mouths shut and rebuild the damn organization and they can’t even do that…

AlexanderESmith ,

AI tools can reduce the financial burden of hiring human writing assistants

... Are MFs hiring teams to help them with the "let's do a fun writing project" month?

I admit that I haven't been keeping track of NaNoRiMo since I heard about it a few decades ago, but isn't the point of it to commit to that personal writing project, and having accountability partners and stuff?

Anyway; Fuck AI books, in whole or part. If you can't write, then don't write. If you write shitty, then write shitty. You'll either get better with practice, or you wont, but it's better than cheating on homework that you assigned to yourself.

  • All
  • Subscribed
  • Moderated
  • Favorites
  • •
  • [email protected]
  • random
  • lifeLocal
  • goranko
  • All magazines
    •