Yeah and weirdly that’s about the only thing I respect about Catholics- they actually can and do tell mofos “you aint Catholic, those aint Catholic beliefs” so they can kind of ‘police their own’. Whereas I can say I’m a Baptist Zoroastrian that believes Jesus was actually Zeus and nobody can tell me that’s not a Baptist belief. Not that I think Catholic dogma makes an sense on its own but at least they don’t allow any old shmuck to fork it.
But yeah I don’t think there’s a way to keep the secular community and drop the religious tribalism, at least not without a Moonhaven style guided cultural reboot but to me that’s less plausible than Jesus actually being Zeus.